big apple bagel guests swear by it—custard butter tastes like heaven

Sun, 03 May 2026 08:24:10 +0000

Big Apple Bagel Guests Swear By It: Why Custard Butter Tastes Like Heaven When you step into the cozy corner of a Big Apple Bagel, one item stands out above the rest—custard butter. More than just a spread, it’s a beloved ritual that transforms a simple bagel into pure culinary bliss. Across countless reviews and glowing personal testimonials, one truth echoes again and again: custard butter tastes like heaven. ### A Signature Taste That Defines the Experience At Big Apple Bagel, custard butter isn’t just any butter—it’s a carefully crafted signature spread made with rich, high-quality ingredients designed to deliver an unmatched creamy, velvety mouthfeel and a deeply satisfying sweetness balanced with just a hint of warmth. Locals and visitors alike claim it’s impossible to choose between two, let alone skip it altogether.